Brighton midfielder James Milner has yet to decide whether he will continue his playing career next season.
The 40-year-old made history last week by becoming the all-time appearance leader in the Premier League (since 1992). The veteran has now featured in 654 matches in England’s top flight, setting a remarkable benchmark for longevity and consistency.
Next season, Milner could also break another significant record. The current mark for the oldest player in Premier League history belongs to Teddy Sheringham, who played at the age of 40 years and 272 days. Milner would have the opportunity to surpass that milestone if he extends his career.
Milner’s contract with Brighton & Hove Albion expires this summer. Head coach Fabian Hürzeler has publicly expressed his desire for the experienced midfielder to stay, but Milner himself says no final decision has been made.
“Things change very quickly in football, and they change quickly at my age as well,” Milner told The Athletic.
He reflected on a challenging period last season when a knee injury kept him from even lifting his leg properly for half a year.
“Six weeks ago I wasn’t getting many minutes, things weren’t going well and I was frustrated. Now I’ve played more in the last two matches and been involved in winning games. At moments like that, it’s easy to say, of course I’ll play another year.”
When asked whether retirement scares him, Milner was candid.
“No, I wouldn’t say I’m scared of it. It’s difficult to know when the right time has come because I still feel I can do this. But do you keep going until you realise you can’t anymore?”
He also referenced former Liverpool manager Jürgen Klopp, who once advised that when the time to stop comes, a player must step away completely and allow themselves to rest.
“That sounds quite appealing right now,” Milner admitted.
“I’m looking forward to switching off and having time to do what I want. But many people say they miss the routines and the training. When that’s gone, I imagine I’d want to run marathons or do something similar — just to have something to aim for.”
For now, the record-breaking midfielder remains undecided, balancing the pull of competition with the promise of life beyond the pitch.
From 2002 to 2026 📆
— Premier League (@premierleague) February 21, 2026
James Milner has set the all-time appearances record in the Premier League! pic.twitter.com/lw0h1fERlW
About the Author
